ES -- DX/CL -- isee -- cboe put/call -- specialist/public short ratio -- trinq -- trin -- aaii bull ratio -- abx -- cmbx -- cdx -- vxo p&f -- SPX volatility curve -- VIX:VXO skew -- commodity screen -- cot -- conference board

Friday, October 08, 2010

 

LEI deconstructed, update


i haven't run this analysis in a year's time, but it's worth updating now. on twitter i've become vocal in the belief that the united states is headed into a severe double dip that will end all reasonable debate as to whether we are or are not in a depression. the theoretical basis for the notion emerges from the work of richard koo, whose framework of a balance sheet recession leaves little room for expansion given the rolloff of fiscal stimulus spending. i've further been amazed and disturbed by the continuing development of steve keen's stock-flow macro model, which has made enormous strides in the last year.

but, while theory is fine for hypothesis, there is no substitute for evidence. unfortunately there's been enough to convince me.

i last mentioned here the consumer metrics institute's GDP predictor in march. it has since marked out a horrifying path of collapse since peaking in october of last year (coincidentally about the time i last updated this study). CMI has helpfully overlaid the continuing contraction in their real-time transaction data atop the 2008-9 recession in this chart, to frightening effect. this is not theoretical exposition; a large decline in real transactions of consumer goods is behind this movement. i see this as confirmation of thesis.

a second confirmation emerges from a deconstruction of the ECRI's leading indicators on the methodology previously described. with a broken credit mechanism -- total loans and leases is still declining, as it has been for two years now -- and unprecedented federal reserve bank intervention in funding markets, i feel a handful of the LEI components -- yield curve, m2, stocks and the consumer expectations that largely follow stocks -- probably represent broken signals better designed for standard post-war recessions than the depression we're experiencing.

removing their contribution to the LEI reveals the weakness of the stimulus-fueled inventory cycle "recovery" of 2009-10. moreover, for much of this year, the "real" component aggregate was demonstrating outright contraction, with the level peaking in april 2010 -- a sharp warning of an impending return to recession, even as the ECRI LEI as reported set a new high in the last reading of the series. this of course mirrors the contraction reported in CMI data.

a number of regional manufacturing indeces (philly fed, empire state) has also shown a sharp slowdown in the last two months, with inventories again starting to build -- these being coindcident-to-lagging indications of economic activity, it would seem likely that contraction in consumer activity is starting to feed back into the manufacturing chain as CMI has for some time expected. house prices have continued to decline after a tax-credit-induced respite and jobs data has also disappointed, showing little or no recovery in the labor market. i expect these data series will now begin to show more severe deterioration through the end of the year -- following the CMI data and the rate of federal stimulus spending down -- and to remain very weak until the united states government is compelled to return to accelerating deficits in order to offset the debt deflation of the private sector.

Labels: , ,



This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?